Shoreline Vegetation Gets Attention

While I'm glad the issue of oceanfront property owners using plants to grab more beach land is getting attention, I wish the State Legislature would address a bigger matter: we still do NOT have any state law for public beach access minimum standards. All we have for Oahu are "suggested guidelines" by the City Council, which are unenforceable.

Anyhow, if you want to put a stop to overgrown beachfront vegetation by homeowners, there is a bill you can submit testimony in support of: HB1808.

Date/Time/Place: Thursday, Feb. 4th, 2:20 PM, State Capitol Room 325

Please submit testimony online at: http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/emailtestimony

Type in HB1808 where you're asked to enter the measure for the latest hearing info. If the bill advances there will be more hearings, so save your testimony to resend later!

Also, you can view an Olelo program about this subject or watch it on YouTube. Here's more info below:

Rep. Barbara Marumoto discusses Kahala Beach with long-time resident Lucinda Pyles and Dolan Eversole, Coastal Geology Extension Agent, UH Sea Grant College Program. The show identifies the problem of obstruction of lateral access, recreational use and natural beach processes. It provides a historical reference as to why this needs to be addressed now -- before more beaches are lost forever.

Part 1 Click here.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YqerUoevrrw

Part 2 Click here.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WP7fL9ghBHc

Part 3 Click here.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vTDvb1QRlas

The program will also run on Channel 54:
2/28/10 Sun. 7:00 pm
3/1/10 Mon. 9:00 am
3/2/10 Tue. 8:30 am
3/3/10 Wed. 6:00 pm

Beach Land Grab Article

Today's Star-Bulletin ran a good article about the continuing problem of oceanfront property owners making claims on the beach where it has naturally expanded, or by simply growing out vegetation to grab more land (as in the photo above, which was taken last year at Kailua Beach -- note the SPRINKLER HEADS in the plantings).

We have laws saying the beach belongs to the public up to the high water wash, but vegetation is also used to mark boundaries. We have State laws that say one thing, while the individual counties make their own shoreline setback rules. Meanwhile, due to State and county budget shortfalls, personnel are being laid off which means we have less enforcement of existing laws. And no one is really responsible for overseeing our shorelines and beaches -- the State and counties just pass the buck!

Here's the article link.

My wife and I took a walk along Kailua Beach this Thanksgiving weekend. Besides the five houses that are already being rebuilt closer to the water, there are at least two vacant lots where you can be sure new owners will also build right up to the legal setback because others have already done it, and they don't want their views blocked by neighbors who will rebuild closer to the ocean.

Say goodbye to the Kailua Beach we used to love. It's well on the way to becoming another narrow stretch of sand just like Lanikai or Kahala Beach thanks to selfish, short-sighted beachfront property owners who don't give a damn about their impact on Hawaii's beaches. And thank our State and county officials too for not doing anything about it.

Kahala Beach Vegetation Update

The Honolulu Advertiser ran a follow-up story today about the overgrown vegetation that is impeding shoreline access along Kahala Beach. A year ago, the State DLNR notified 12 landowners that they had to cut back the naupaka and other plants that were growing right down to the high water line. To date, only one has complied.

And what's the State's response? Um, well, we don't have the time or money to do anything about it. That's according to Sam Lemmo, the same DLNR guy who opposed my proposal to create a joint State/counties task force to address issues such as this! Why? Because the State and counties both are unwilling (or unable due to jurisdiction problems) to take responsibility for management of our coastlines and beaches.

Unfortunately, the article didn't do a very good job of framing the bigger issues of shoreline management and the need for a Hawaii Coastal Commission to oversee statewide policies. The reporter also took a comment I made about vegetation speeding up erosion out of context, because it made it sound like I was saying natural vegetation increases erosion. That is NOT what I said. I was referring specifically to plantings by landowners in front of homes that were built TOO CLOSE TO THE OCEAN. Besides disturbing the natural ebb and flow of sand and water, just as seawalls do, these artificial plantings are a blatant land grab by those homeowners.

Sheesh. But it was apparent from talking to this reporter that she had no intention of going out herself to check any of the beaches or problems I was talking about. She also didn't bother to speak to Rep. Thielen about the Kailua setbacks bill defeat, which is related to shoreline conservation efforts. Nor did she bother to speak to newly-elected City Councilman Ikaika Anderson, who presumably should have something to say about shoreline setbacks and vegetation, since those matters currently fall under county jurisdiction.

Anyhow, you can read the article by clicking here. Half-assed reporting is better than no follow-up at all, I suppose.

Advertiser link:
http://www.honoluluadvertiser.com/article/20090601/NEWS01/906010331